skip to content

All projects: Gel, Jobs, Good Todo, Games, Uncle Mark, Blog, Bit Literacy

Broken: Upgrade "reward"

The program was working fine. For months. Never a problem. But I kept getting those popups "helpfully" reminding me that there was a new version.

OK, fine, I thought. What's the harm, I'll just upgrade it real quick.

Then I tried running it again. Oops:

camino-error.png

Maybe this time I'll learn my lesson! If there's no immediate, pressing need to get the new version, ignore the reminders. Hang on to the version that works until there's a good reason to change.

In other words: If it ain't broke, don't upgrade it.


10 Comments:

schwal — Apr 6, '09 — 10:12 PM

It depends entirely on the software, and the upgrades. But browsers should ALWAYS be upgraded, as the upgrades are almost always security related. But on an Intel mac, Safari (or Firefox) is the prefered browser anyway.

Duff — Apr 7, '09 — 12:47 AM

This could also be said about the field of personal development, as in the Lifehacker book "Upgrade Your Life." If only more people followed this simple, conservative logic, we would certainly have a saner world.

Paul Schreiber — Apr 7, '09 — 1:34 AM

The message you're seeing sometimes appears in inappropriate situations (i.e. there probably is no architecture mismatch).

You can check by running "file /Applications/Camino.app/Contents/MacOS/Camino"

Mine looks like this:
Camino: Mach-O universal binary with 2 architectures
Camino (for architecture i386): Mach-O executable i386
Camino (for architecture ppc): Mach-O executable ppc

And ls -l:
-rwxr-xr-x@ 1 paul paul 28169276 Mar 27 11:52 /Applications/Camino.app/Contents/MacOS/Camino*

I suspect the only problem is with the updating mechanism itself. Just download a fresh version of Camino.

Tom — Apr 7, '09 — 2:51 AM

This is so so true. I can't count the number of times I've made my life harder by updating programs. If it's not security related like schwal mentioned, I'm inclined not to go for the updates any more.

Jonathan — Apr 7, '09 — 5:23 AM

I had the same thing happen to me just yesterday, but with a different app. I had to go to the app's website and download the PowerPC version manually. The failure here is really on the part of the developer, who either doesn't have a Universal Binary, or doesn't ensure that the app downloads the proper Intel vs. PowerPC version.

Mark — Apr 7, '09 — 8:19 AM

The latest Camino update included security fixes also. Firefox is incredibly slow on the Mac. Camino is significantly faster. And there are probably few or no exploits designed for it to begin with.

Mark Hurst Author Profile Page — Apr 7, '09 — 9:11 AM

thanks, all - i agree, security is a good reason to upgrade; and yes, camino is quite a good browser! simple and fast.

paul - thanks for the tip & details. downloading it again seemed likely to be the fix.

Michael Barr — Apr 7, '09 — 9:25 AM

It is especially important not to naively upgrade from the iPhone App Store, from which there is NO going back. For example, the latest version of the Facebook app is buggier than the one it claimed to improve.

Julia — Apr 7, '09 — 2:30 PM

It may be worthwhile to postpone upgrading to make sure there's no fallout from an upgrade (Google and support forums are your friends here), but given that new versions of software (especially web browsers) often include new security fixes, withholding on upgrading until forced seems like a bad idea.

Doug Jones — Apr 21, '09 — 9:09 PM

Gah. I tried to upgrade my Garmin GPS maps last night, and the upgrade bricked the unit. Now I get to spend a few days thrashing with customer service to get it working again. Wish I'd come across this 24 hours ago...


Email Newsletter




All Projects from Good Experience

Gel Conference
Our annual get-together in New York
Jobs Board
Post or find a job
Good Todo
The world's best todo list
Good Experience Games
The best games online
Uncle Mark Gift Guide
The guide to technology and life
Good Experience Blog & Newsletter
Mark Hurst explores good experience

"...the Elements of Style for the digital age."
- Seth Godin
Bit Literacy, the book by Mark Hurst, shows how to solve email and info overload.